Matthew's Pizza has established itself as a beloved local gem since its inception. The passion for quality ingredients and authentic Italian recipes shines through every dish. The ambiance may lean toward casual, but the food definitely does not compromise on flavor. Here, the heart of the operation lies in the dough—made fresh daily. This sets the stage for a remarkable pizza experience. Diners rave about the classic Red Pizza, praised not only for its crust but also for the perfect balance of cheese and sauce.
The White Pizza is a hit among those who love a creamy indulgence. Each pizza is available in both 14" and 16" sizes, making it perfect for sharing with friends or indulging alone.
Beyond pizzas, Matthew's offers an array of hearty and satisfying entrees, including Italian hoagies, mega-sized cheesesteaks, and a variety of specialty sandwiches. Signature dishes such as the Chicken Parmesan Dinner or Baked Ziti offer hearty options for diner who want a full meal experience. I particularly enjoy the Italian Hoagie, which strikes a perfect balance of flavors with fresh ingredients.
In addition to dining in or taking out, some patrons opt for catering services offered by Matthew's for special occasions or events.
The commitment to service extends beyond the food itself. Every staff member shines with enthusiasm and a willingness to help customers choose dishes that meet their cravings. With a place rooted deeply in the local community, Matthew's Pizza doesn't just serve food—it serves nostalgia, comfort, and authentic Italian goodness.
